| Once Upon a Time (All) |
| If Only (Cinderella and Animals) |
| Come One, Come All (Messengers and Villagers) |
| Catch His Eye! (Gertrude, Pearl, Stepmother, and Cinderella) |
| Come One, Come All: Reprise (Villagers, Gertrude, Pearl, and Stepmother) |
| Couldn't, Shouldn't, or Won't! (Godmother, Cinderella, and Animals) |
| A Waltz (Prince, Cinderella, and Villagers) |
| Midnight! (Instrumental) |
| If the Shoe Fits (Prince and Villagers) |
| Once Upon a Time: Reprise (All) |
| Once Upon a Time (All) |
| If Only (Cinderella and Animals) |
| Come One, Come All (Messengers and Villagers) |
| Catch His Eye! (Gertrude, Pearl, Stepmother, and Cinderella) |
| Come One, Come All: Reprise (Villagers, Gertrude, Pearl, and Stepmother) |
| Couldn't, Shouldn't, or Won't! (Godmother, Cinderella, and Animals) |
| A Waltz (Prince, Cinderella, and Villagers) |
| Midnight! (Instrumental) |
| If the Shoe Fits (Prince and Villagers) |
| Once Upon a Time: Reprise (All) |
| Once Upon a Time (All) |
| If Only (Cinderella and Animals) |
| Come One, Come All (Messengers and Villagers) |
| Catch His Eye! (Gertrude, Pearl, Stepmother, and Cinderella) |
| Come One, Come All: Reprise (Villagers, Gertrude, Pearl, and Stepmother) |
| Couldn't, Shouldn't, or Won't! (Godmother, Cinderella, and Animals) |
| A Waltz (Prince, Cinderella, and Villagers) |
| Midnight! (Instrumental) |
| If the Shoe Fits (Prince and Villagers) |
| Once Upon a Time: Reprise (All) |
| Once Upon a Time (All) |
| If Only (Cinderella and Animals) |
| Come One, Come All (Messengers and Villagers) |
| Catch His Eye! (Gertrude, Pearl, Stepmother, and Cinderella) |
| Come One, Come All: Reprise (Villagers, Gertrude, Pearl, and Stepmother) |
| Couldn't, Shouldn't, or Won't! (Godmother, Cinderella, and Animals) |
| A Waltz (Prince, Cinderella, and Villagers) |
| Midnight! (Instrumental) |
| If the Shoe Fits (Prince and Villagers) |
| Once Upon a Time: Reprise (All) |
